Top 10 Best Sicilian Olive Oil Based On Scores

Last Update:

You can trust our selection for Sicilian Olive Oil Reviews. Because We have worked hard studying and analyzing 52355 reviews for Sicilian Olive Oil and rating them. It was a difficult job to list only ten products for Sicilian Olive Oil where thousands of them available online. I hope it will help you to take final decision for Best Sicilian Olive Oil.

Best Sicilian Olive Oil
Disclaimer: As An Amazon Associate I Earn From Qualifying Purchases.
NoProductScoreAction
1Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil9.8Buy Now
2Oro di Sicilia Green Gold Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 16.9 Fluid Ounce Can - Cold-Pressed in Sicily9.2Buy Now
3Frantoia Barbera Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 1 lt9.2Buy Now
4Bono Sicilian Certified PDO Val Di Mazara Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 16.9 oz9Buy Now
5Barbera Frantoia Sicilian Extra Virgin Olive oil8.8Buy Now
6Cento - Oil Cured Black Olives8.6Buy Now
7Zahara Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Italy - Sicilian Pure EVOO - Premium 2021 Early Harvest Cold Pressed - Multiple Award Winner from Oleificio Guccione - 16.9 fl oz (500ml) Bottle With Beautiful Gift Box8.4Buy Now
8Papa Vince Olive Oil Extra Virgin Unblended First Cold Pressed8.4Buy Now
9Paesano Usda Organic Sicilian Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 34oz. Bottle (Pack of 2)8.2Buy Now
10Il Colle Del Gusto Sicilian Pistachios Spread with Extra Virgin Olive Oil8.2Buy Now

Comparison Chart for Best Sicilian Olive Oil

We’ve scanned 52355 reviews for you. If you are looking for the Sicilian Olive Oil than this review article may help you.

Table Of Content:

1. Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil

  • Net quantity of 101 ounces
  • Cold-pressed oil
  • When the tins are first opened, the oil is cloudy with a green hue, herbaceous aroma and ‘pizzicante’ flavor.
  • Will mellow slightly and become clearer as the sediment drops to the bottom of the tin

2. Oro di Sicilia Green Gold Extra Virgin Olive Oil – 16.9 Fluid Ounce Can – Cold-Pressed in Sicily

  • ORO DI SICILIA – Oro di Sicilia is an exclusive partnership between Tomaso Asaro, heralded Sicilian olive oil producer, Frank Castronovo and Frank Falcinelli, NYC-based chefs and restaurateurs.
  • SICILIAN OLIVES – Oro di Sicilia Green Gold Extra Virgin Olive Oil is made from legendary olives: Biancolilla, Nocellara del Belice and Cerasuola.
  • EXTRA VIRGIN, NON-GMO – The Asaro Estate’s authentic farming methods produce non-GMO olives in a biodynamic way, free from chemicals.
  • A HEALTHFUL ADDITION TO YOUR DIET – Olive oil is rich in powerful antioxidants, vitamin D, and monounsaturated fats that help to reduce inflammation.
  • CRAFTED FOR ALL – Oro di Sicilia Green Gold EVOO is designed by Chefs for everyday cooks.

3. Frantoia Barbera Extra Virgin Olive Oil – 1 lt

  • Best Before 2023
  • Fruity Flavor, Spicy Aroma, Gourmet
  • First Cold Pressed
  • Product of Italy, Unfiltered extra virgin olive oil,
  • Kosher

4. Bono Sicilian Certified PDO Val Di Mazara Extra Virgin Olive Oil – 16.9 oz

  • Certified DOP Val di mazara oil
  • All olives used to make this precious oil as well as the factory are found in Val di mazara region
  • 100 percentage Sicilian certified oil
  • The package dimension of the product is 12.7″L x 8.4″W x 6.2″H

5. Barbera Frantoia Sicilian Extra Virgin Olive oil

  • Three varieties of olives: Nocellara, Cerasuola and Biancolilla are used for this oil.
  • Can be used raw on fish, fresh cheese, salad, vegetables and bread.
  • Product of Italy

6. Cento – Oil Cured Black Olives

  • Whole Mediterranean Black Olives
  • All Natural
  • Sun Dried & Oil Cured for Authentic Italian Flavor
  • Enjoy as an Appetizer or in Salad
  • 2)- 7 oz. Jars

7. Zahara Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Italy - Sicilian Pure EVOO - Premium 2021 Early Harvest Cold Pressed - Multiple Award Winner from Oleificio Guccione - 16.9 fl oz (500ml) Bottle With Beautiful Gift Box

  • PREMIUM PRODUCT OF SICILY – since 1966 Oleificio Guccione produces fine olive oil in Chiaramonte Gulfi, a small baroque village in the heart of the Iblei Mountains in the South-Eastern part of Sicily, considered the best area on the island for the production of the highest quality olive oil with polyphenol levels at 400mg/kg on average and low acidity of less than 0.
  • AWARDED AS ONE OF THE BEST IN ITALY – Zahara truly is an Italian work of art.
  • THE MAXIMUM EXPRESSION OF SICILIAN OIL – Zahara is an exceptionally tasty, full bodied and balanced extra virgin olive oil rich in Polyphenols (Antioxidants) and Vitamins, with low acidity, characterized by marked notes of tomato and tomato leaf, mediterranean herbs, thistle, nettle and white pepper.
  • LIMITED ARTISANAL PRODUCTION – Zahara is obtained from the olives “Tonda Iblea”, heritage and stunning variety that belongs uniquely to this territory.
  • THE PERFECT FOOD GIFT – Zahara is the perfect gift for all foodies.

8. Papa Vince Olive Oil Extra Virgin Unblended First Cold Pressed

  • Early Harvest 2020/21, Exp.
  • High in polyphenols: 420 mg/kg at the time of bottling
  • High in Vitamin E (DV 30%) – only high quality extra virgin olive oils list vitamins in their nutritional panel.
  • Delightful Peppery Finish, Fresh & Green with hints of tomatoes and artichokes – Great for Keto, Whole 30, Vegan and detoxing.
  • Unfiltered, Unblended, 100% the juice of the fruit of the olive made by our family in Sicily, Italy since 1935.

9. Paesano Usda Organic Sicilian Extra Virgin Olive Oil – 34oz. Bottle (Pack of 2)

  • Certified USDA Organic, this award-winning extra virgin olive oil is unfiltered
  • has its very unique green color, spicy taste and herbaceous flavor
  • The Paesano is also particularly rich in polyphenols, which are known for their antioxidant effects and have been linked to lower risk of cancer, heart disease and some neurological diseases.
  • It is a great finishing oil for salad dressings and to drizzle on soups or pastas.

10. Il Colle Del Gusto Sicilian Pistachios Spread with Extra Virgin Olive Oil

  • Pistachio lovers will want to eat it right out of the jar
  • Use Pistacchiosa as you would chocolate sauce, spooned over fresh ricotta cheese or frozen yogurt or stirred into rice pudding.
  • From Lazio Italy

How To Choose The Best Sicilian Olive Oil

Does the thought of finding a great Sicilian Olive Oil stress you out? Has your mind been juggling between choices when it comes to buying Sicilian Olive Oil in general, specifically regarding which model to choose?
If that’s the case, know that you’re not alone. Many people find it tough to buy the perfect Sicilian Olive Oil for themselves. We understand the stress associated with the buying process!

Since you’re here, you are obviously curious about Sicilian Olive Oil. You’ve been bombarded with information, so you need to find a reputable source with credible options before you make any decisions on which product would be best for your needs.

There are many sources that’ll provide you with that information- buying guides or ratings websites, word-of-mouth testimonials from friends or family members, online forums where users share their personal experiences, product reviews specifically found all over the internet and YouTube channels. Only thorough research will ensure that you get the right product.

But that’s not always easy, right? That's why we've taken time to compile a list of the best Sicilian Olive Oil in today's market, on your behalf, so that there will be no more worries for you.

How did we come up with the list, you ask? How did we create this buying guide?

  • First, our algorithms collected as much information available about these products from trusted sources.
  • We employed both Artificial Intelligence and large data volume to validate all collected information.
  • Then our AI ranked them on their quality-to-price ratio using industry-standard criteria that let us pick the best Sicilian Olive Oil currently on the market!
The products aren’t chosen randomly. We consider several criteria before assembling a list. Some of the criteria are discussed below-

  1. Brand Value: What happens when you go for a not-so-reputable brand just because the price seems cheap? Well, the chance of getting a short-lasting product goes higher. That’s because the renowned brands have a reputation to maintain, others don’t.


Top Sicilian Olive Oil brands try to offer some unique features that make them stand out in the crowd. Thus hopefully, you’ll find one ideal product or another in our list.

  1. Features: You don’t need heaps of features, but useful ones. We look at the features that matter and choose the top Sicilian Olive Oil based on that.
  2. Specifications: Numbers always help you measure the quality of a product in a quantitative way. We try to find products of higher specifications, but with the right balance.
  3. Customer Ratings: The hundreds of customers using the Sicilian Olive Oil before you won’t say wrong, would they? Better ratings mean better service experienced by a good number of people.
  4. Customer Reviews: Like ratings, customer reviews give you actual and trustworthy information, coming from real-world consumers about the Sicilian Olive Oil they used.
  5. Seller Rank: Now, this is interesting! You don’t just need a good Sicilian Olive Oil, you need a product that is trendy and growing in sales. It serves two objectives. Firstly, the growing number of users indicates the product is good. Secondly, the manufacturers will hopefully provide better quality and after-sales service because of that growing number.
  6. Value For The Money: They say you get what you pay for. Cheap isn’t always good. But that doesn’t mean splashing tons of money on a flashy but underserving product is good either. We try to measure how much value for the money you can get from your Sicilian Olive Oil before putting them on the list.
  7. Durability: Durability and reliability go hand to hand. A robust and durable Sicilian Olive Oil will serve you for months and years to come.
  8. Availability: Products come and go, new products take the place of the old ones. Probably some new features were added, some necessary modifications were done. What’s the point of using a supposedly good Sicilian Olive Oil if that’s no longer continued by the manufacturer? We try to feature products that are up-to-date and sold by at least one reliable seller, if not several.
  9. Negative Ratings: Yes, we take that into consideration too! When we pick the top rated Sicilian Olive Oil on the market, the products that got mostly negative ratings get filtered and discarded.
These are the criteria we have chosen our Sicilian Olive Oil on. Does our process stop there? Heck, no! The most important thing that you should know about us is, we're always updating our website to provide timely and relevant information.

Since reader satisfaction is our utmost priority, we have a final layer of filtration. And that is you, the reader! If you find any Sicilian Olive Oil featured here Incorrect, irrelevant, not up to the mark, or simply outdated, please let us know. Your feedback is always welcome and we’ll try to promptly correct our list as per your reasonable suggestion.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.